Big Brother 18 Predictions: Superlative Winners Announced

Your votes are in on the new Big Brother 18 Houseguests for our preseason superlatives voting and predictions. We asked you to cast your votes based only on first impressions from their initial interviews and bio details as a fun way to see just how well you could read the new cast.

Big Brother 18's cast of new Houseguests
Big Brother 18’s cast of new Houseguests – Source: CBS

Now as the Big Brother season is about to start we’ll get to watch along and see just how your picks performed for everything from the serious “first evicted” and “season winner” down to the silly “streaker” and “Diary Room screamer.” Let’s get these awards started!

Most Likely To Be Evicted First: Bronte D’Acquisto

Bronte D'Acquisto - Big Brother 18 Houseguest

Bronte D’Acquisto beat out her fellow HGs for this unfortunate honor with 19.9% of the vote leading Glenn Garcia (15.9%) and Paul Abrahamian (10.7%). Granted, after watching her interview with Jeff I think I’d be glad to see her go too and it doesn’t seem impossible for that to happen.

In the past seven seasons we’ve seen four males and three females go first, so the edge goes to another male, but last season we saw Joey go home for her trouble making ways. Considering Bronte discussed her plans to stir up situations she could put herself on a similar trajectory.

Update: This honor went to Glenn who was evicted during the two-night premiere.

Most Likely To Shout/Scream In Diary Room: Glenn Garcia

Glenn Garcia - Big Brother 18 Houseguest

Every season someone has to Dan it up in the DR room and this year the presumptive honor goes to Glenn Garcia with 18.9% of the vote just ahead of Paul Abrahamian (17.9%) and Bronte D’Acquisto (15.3%). All three look like they could be good picks for the role, but I could definitely see Glenn, the Big Brother fan, getting excited and shouting away in the blue room.

Most Likely To Streak: Paul Abrahamian

Paul Abrahamian - Big Brother 18 Hosueguest

Either fans are hoping to see Paul Abrahamian make this move or they think his “I don’t give a…” attitude make him the most likely to ditch his close and run the house with 25.6% of the vote. He just barely beat out Paulie Calafiore (24.9%) for this honor while Victor Arroyo (17.7%) came in third. If the internet’s archives are to be trusted, Paulie sure likes to spend a lot of time mostly undressed so he may give Paul a run for his money.

Update: Victor took the upset victory on this one during our second night of Feeds.

Most Likely To Start A BB18 Catchphrase: Paulie Calafiore

Paulie Calafiore - Big Brother 18

My lanta, do we really need another overly used phrase to get us through the Big Brother summer? Absolutely not, but you know we’ll get one and readers have predicted Paulie Calafiore with 16.8% of the vote to be our provider. He beat out Jozea Flores (13.6%) and Zakiyah Everette (11.2%) for this responsibility.

Most Likely To Scrub a Toilet with a Toothbrush: Paul Abrahamian

Paul Abrahamian - Big Brother 18 Hosueguest

Another category win for Paul Abrahamian with 16.7% of the voters expecting ol’ Paul to pull a BB2 Shannon move and volunteer another’s toothbrush for toilet cleaning duties. If you’re not familiar with that one, then check out the video below for some classic Big Brother. And yes, she had to buy him a new toothbrush, but no, he didn’t use the dirty one.

Next up, the most likely to have a showmance this summer on Big Brother, cause that’s always a great idea, right?


Commenting Rules: Keep the conversation civil and on topic. If your comment does not add to the conversation, it will be removed. Debate intelligently. Insulting the author, Big Brother Network, or other commentators will result in comment removal and possible ban. Any comments with links or flagged words will go into moderation before approval. Anything we deem as spam will not be approved. Comments left in ALL-CAPS will be deleted regardless of content.


  1. Can not wait till it starts and the 4 ‘extras” are revealed. I think that the above could all change depending ion the 4 person twist.

    • It was a great concept on paper. That’s probably why they did it twice. But it was abused by the most brilliant player ever, Derrick. There were way too many loopholes. Production should’ve changed the rules the second season they did it, so you can’t abuse the system so easily. Because by the time it came around, everyone knew all the tricks and secrets of how to make it work towards your advantage, thanks to Derrick.

  2. I’m thinking “the old guy” will fly under the radar because “the kids” will not see him as a threat.

  3. Wow…some interesting choices. I still haven’t listened to the interviews, but based upon photos ONLY–pretty shallow of me– I’m kind of agreeing with the choices…except Vanessa’s sister winning. I think people voted for her ONLY because V went so far last year.

    • I too didn’t read or watch videos, and didn’t take poll bc it seemed so judgmental not seeing their behavior. i did see a commercial and one of my judgments I made from their pics as an annoying/drama/attitude girl may be right. if that’s true, hope she’s evicted first

      • I think the reason I can’t listen to the interviews, is because I need to see them in the house, like you, BHFan. Plus, I don’t want to get to know any of them until I find out who the other four people are.

Comments are closed.